Learn how warrants, pending charges, and convictions appear on employment background checks and how employers can review them fairly.
Understanding Warrants and Background Checks
When conducting criminal background checks for employment, employers often ask: do warrants show up on a background check? To answer this, it helps to first understand what a warrant is and how it differs from related terms like arrests, pending cases, and convictions.
What Is an Open Warrant?
An open warrant is an official order issued by a court authorizing law enforcement to take a person into custody. It signals that an individual has not appeared for a scheduled court date or that charges have been filed but the person has not yet been arrested.
Arrests vs. Warrants vs. Pending Cases vs. Convictions
- Arrest: This is when law enforcement physically takes a person into custody based on probable cause.
- Pending Case: A charge has been filed, but the case is still in process and not yet resolved.
- Conviction: The court has found the individual guilty of a crime.
A warrant is different because it usually precedes an arrest. It indicates a legal order but does not mean the person has been taken into custody yet.
How Warrants Appear on Background Checks
Whether a warrant shows up on a criminal background check depends on the type of search and the jurisdiction involved.
Types of Criminal Background Checks
Background checks can include various levels of searches, national, state, county, or federal. For example, a county criminal search may reveal active warrants or pending cases because local courts maintain up-to-date records on their cases. On the other hand, some broader checks may only show convictions or arrests, not open warrants.
The presence of a warrant on a background report also depends on how quickly the information is updated and what records the background screening company accesses.
Jurisdiction Matters
Courts operate at different levels, municipal, county, state, and federal, and each may have separate records. Warrants are generally issued and recorded at the county or municipal level. Therefore, a search that includes county court records is more likely to reveal open warrants or pending charges.
Reporting Limits Under Federal and State Laws
The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) governs what can be reported in employment background checks. It places limits on what types of criminal records can be disclosed and how they are presented.
Additionally, many states have their own rules that may restrict reporting of certain records, such as open warrants or pending charges, to protect applicants’ privacy and ensure fairness.
Because these rules vary widely, some warrants or pending charges may not appear on a background report, while others might.
Handling Pending Matters Fairly and Consistently
Employers face challenges when background checks reveal pending charges, open warrants, or other unresolved legal matters. It’s important to approach these situations thoughtfully.
The Individualized-Assessment Approach
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) encourages employers to evaluate criminal information on a case-by-case basis. This means considering the nature of the offense, how much time has passed, and the relevance to the job before making hiring decisions.
Applying this individualized-assessment approach helps employers avoid unfair bias and promotes consistent, fair treatment of all candidates.
Why Employers Should Work with Professional Screeners
Navigating warrants, pending charges, and criminal records can be complex. Reliable background screening providers like SaffHire help employers obtain accurate, compliant reports nationwide.
SaffHire understands the nuances of different jurisdictions and reporting rules. Their expertise allows employers to get clear insights while respecting legal boundaries and fairness principles.
Final Thoughts
Whether warrants show up on an employment background check depends on the type of search and jurisdiction, as well as federal and state reporting rules. Understanding these differences helps employers make informed decisions.
Employers should treat pending matters with care, applying consistent and individualized assessments to promote fairness.
Call us at 888-588-1733 for more information or fill out a contact form.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Employers should consult legal counsel or compliance experts regarding specific background screening questions or concerns.
SaffHire helps employers build background screening packages based on role, industry, risk level, and compliance needs. Contact SaffHire to review the right screening package for your hiring process.
Need background checks for your next hires?
Tell us what roles you're hiring for and we'll recommend the right screening package for your team.

